Skip to content

It’s AI’s universe, we only live in it. Seriously.

The Slopiverse could certainly explain a few things.

3 min read
Photo by Vitaly Gariev / Unsplashn

In the past, I have speculated That we may all be the products of a relatively benign, if neglectful, creator. (Specifically, Katie, a 11-year-old who received a Grow Your Own Universe kit from an overworked mom who knows her daughter likes “science stuff,” but has never paid much attention to the details) Only now … I think this is too hopeful. The truth could be far worse.

In fact, it almost certainly is.

In 2003, philosopher Nick Bostrum put a somewhat scientific foundation under two millennia of dreaming butterflies and half-drunken pub talk. A simple version of Bostrum’s argument runs like this: If it is possible, or ever will be possible, to simulate a universe with the fidelity we currently experience, then the odds are that any universe you are in, including this one, is simulated. Simply because, once you can stir up one universe, why not make a bunch?

Like all the best versions of Simulation Theory, it’s intrinsically untestable, but awesomely demeaning. We are not just fakes, but one in an infinite series of knockoffs.

The best we can do at the moment when it comes to the make-a-universe business, is probably found in video games. There are games with incredibly lifelike characters, detailed surroundings, and amazingly realized societies, like the just released Grand Theft Auto VI. There are also procedurally generated games capable of simulating every rock and blade of grass in a galaxy actually larger than the Milky Way, like No Man’s Sky.

However, despite their ability to rake in billions and make the Mano-o-sphere have fits, it seems unlikely that any of the ambitious thugs populating sim-Miami, or the various aliens seeking the home of the Atlas, has anything like genuine self-awareness. We think that they don’t think. For now.

But you can see where this is going.

In the last few weeks, with the release of the latest iterations of LLM, app stores have become flooded with AI clones. The combination of AI-enhanced coding tools and more powerful models has made it increasingly easy to re-engineer the behavior of even complex applications, including games, make a few tweaks as a gesture toward copyright laws, and drop a work-alike clone right beside the original. Then another. And another.

The AAA bestsellers may still be hand-crafter works reflecting hundreds of thousands of hours of loving human attention. But most of the titles occupying the virtual shelves are not. And everyday, the percentage of the marketplace that belongs to AI only grows larger. The same is true for books. Or songs. Or videos. Stick a random pin in Amazon, or Steam, or Spotify, and the odds are it will meet only AI-generated content.

Combine this with Bostrum’s theory and it brings you to a truly horrible place.

If it’s possible to simulate a universe, then the universe we all share is probably simulated. If it’s possible to generate such a simulation through AI, then any universe is much more likely to be AI-slop than the product of even the most neglectful being.

Not only are we in a simulated universe, it’s not even a AAA simulation.

What if we not the result of an advanced race deliberately simulating the world of their more primitive ancestors? What if we are not even resting in a neglected, dusty shoebox after the divine Katie got a new pet? What if we, and everything we’ve ever known, are simply number three out of four options produced by the latest pass of a trans-dimensional Midjourney? What if God is simply a prompt engineer who never came closer to His creation than specifying that half the population should come with boobs?

Someone has probably already run the first chapter of Genesis past Claude. I don’t want to see what came out,

The Slopiverse could certainly explain a few things. Why so many beetles? Why do things keep turning into crabs? Why is there Donald Trump? Why do bad things happen to good people? Why can’t we know both the spin and position of a fundamental particle? Why can’t we have a second season of Lanterns even if James Gunn got fired? Really, this universe has all the signs a prompt that ended with “and make it photorealistic.”

Maybe, just maybe, we were supposed to have six fingers. 

The moral implications of the Slopiverse are both profound—is the consumption of human-created media by AI models really just an Ouroboros of content recycling—and ridiculous. Or maybe it’s all just ridiculous. After all, the slop may not just be infinitely wide, but infinitely deep.

Eventually, any prolonged contemplation of the Slopiverse presents the same paradox as Simulation Theory always has: It can explain anything, but prove nothing.

With AI, this seems even more true. Hey, Grok, end program.

Mark Sumner

Author of The Evolution of Everything, On Whetsday, Devil's Tower, and 43 other books.

We rely on your support!

We're a community-funded site with no advertisements or big-money backers—we rely only on you, our readers. Click here to upgrade to a (completely optional!) $5 per month paid subscription, Or click here to send a one-time payment of any amount.

The more support we have, the faster you'll see us grow!

Comments

We want Uncharted Blue to be a welcoming and progressive space.

Before commenting, make sure you've read our Community Guidelines.