There's already been considerable ink spilled in the debate over whether Sen. Minority Leader Chuck Schumer should keep his party-leading position when Democrats take over the Senate. Schumer's advocates point to his (1) fundraising, (2) candidate recruitment efforts, and (3) the plain truth that few Democratic senators are going to be able to stomach picking a fight with the man given (1) and (1). Schumer's camp has been insisting that his elevation to majority leader is a done deal; they've only doubled down on those assertions since Sen. Chris Van Hollen publicly announced he'd be challenging Schumer.
We can debate the differences of policy between the two senators, or come up with alleged poison-pill stances in an effort to disqualify one or both, or imagine the appearance of a new theoretical leader who every Democrat agrees with 100% of the time, but the core vote is whether to keep Schumer as the one of the Democratic Party's most publicly conspicuous voice or to not do that.
But there is one very big reason not to do it, one that is not Schumer's own fault or under his control: For the last 10 years, voter approval ratings for the Democratic Party have gone from dismal to even worse. That has happened despite unprecedented scandal erupting from every orifice of Republicanism, the mainstreaming of gutter racism and extremist conspiracy theories directly into government agencies themselves, and the clear-cut real-world demonstration of Democratic policies, via Biden, to Republican corruption and maladministration under Trump.
And, through all of that, Sen. Chuck Schumer was a top face and voice of the Democratic Party.
It took the destruction of large parts of government, the construction of concentration camps, Unidentified "homeland security" thugs shooting Americans on our streets, soaring prices, and a new incompetently-premised war that spiked fuel prices with zero obvious scenarios for fixing any of it to convince American voters to reject a crooked and despicable authoritarian movement.
But that doesn't mean voters trust Democrats now. Democrats did not win a historic mandate two weeks ago. The mandate was against Republicanism, and Democrats held the advantage of being the party that wasn't that.
There is no reason to expect that voters will now embrace the same Democratic Party, in the same form, that voters two years ago found dismal enough to be willing to instead re-elevate a felonious crank seditionist. We can debate about why that might be, and we can complain about the obvious unfairness and/or outright idiocy of an, on balance, politically illiterate electorate coming to such conclusions.
But that is the history. Paired against obvious buffoonery, authoritarian vulgarity, expanding racism, grotesque and growing misogyny, and the curtailing of rights we all presumed to be settled before the Supreme Court and a collection of Ken Paxtons decided they weren't anymore, the Democratic Party has managed, with billions of dollars spent, to fight their way into middling parity with all of it.
You can blame oligarchic media. You can blame Elon Musk and his fellow billionaires, all willing to shove near-unlimited funds to whoever promised them the most crooked favors. You can blame voters for giving a hundred times more attention to a favored sports team than to our national health. You're right about all of it, and it doesn't matter because we are here, right now, on this spot, and none of those things are going to get any better in the next two years or twenty unless something happens to make it so.
The Democratic Party remains unpopular and distrusted. It remains the butt of jokes; the public perception (and the perception even in the party's own base) is of an inept technocracy that considers new convolutions of tax policy to be the highest form of strategizing but which just as often seems to join with Republican leaders to insist that no, actually, America can no longer have nice things and voters are childish for demanding them.
Sen. Chuck Schumer is the poster boy for that characterization of the Democratic Party. Much of that is his own fault—but it's going to be difficult if not impossible to present the Democratic Party as the party of change based on the say-so of one of the most prominent national symbols of a Democratic Party that has not.
If there is one flaw that makes Chuck Schumer the anti-man of the moment, it is that he is a charismaless public void. Yes, I know that's insulting, but some people are able to charm an audience and some are not, and no matter how effective Schumer may or may not be behind the scenes, as the public face of the party he seems to personify many of the stereotypes of Democratic inaction.
To say the man is not light on his feet is an understatement: He is the butt of jokes. Constantly. There are two running jokes that define the Democratic Party among its own activists: The first is that no matter what problem you present to the Democratic caucus, the solution will always be targeted tax cuts. Did ICE erroneously toss you in one of its new camps, despite you being an American citizen, and leave you there for eight weeks? What if we allow people illegally held in concentration camps to deduct whatever legal fees they incurred while trying to be released. What if we provide a $5,000 tax credit to every American who's had a bone broken by roving DHS agents screaming around city streets in unmarked rental vans. What if we inch our way towards a fiscal half-solution, would that convince you the problem is solved?
The second joke is, of course, egg prices. Or more broadly, Schumer's particular habit of ignoring viral issues and outrages, then reliably coming back a week after everyone else has stopped talking about them with some transparently focus-grouped-to-oblivion quip.
Yes, egg prices spiked. It was a cultural moment of significance because it demonstrated something much larger about the apparent fragility of the economy. Thank you for noticing two weeks after everyone else had their say; the discourse has now moved on to some new outrage that will also be ignored by Democratic leaders until that moment too has passed.
To say the Democratic Party response to cultural moments is sclerotic is to sugarcoat it; party leaders seem to intentionally avoid moments of cultural significance, seemingly due to an institutional terror at the thought of making a gaffe.
Nor are party leaders like Schumer willing to project outrage when outrage is the thing most needed. And that is deadly, because the wave election that routed Republicans in federal, state, and local elections to an extent not seen since the Watergate scandal was based almost entirely on American voter outrage.
Among 2024 Trump voters, disapproval of the president's handling of immigration/deportations predicted voting for Democrats in the midterms more than views on prices did, and their views on his corruption scandals predicted 2026 vote about as well. www.gelliottmorris.com/p/2026-11-17...
— G Elliott Morris (@gelliottmorris.com) 2026-11-17T12:08:13.561Z
Deportations. Corruption. Prices. Few Americans came to the polls to vote against Republicans top-to-bottom because they were enchanted with some new Democratic-proposed tax or transportation policy. They swept Republicans in office as an act of anger. This was a wave premised on disgust, and on vengeance.
If you cannot at least pretend at the same show of righteous outrage that American voters themselves displayed, you are not fit for this moment.
There are Democrats who are willing to show anger for the sake of those harmed by Trumpism. There are those willing to take action, to make a very visible public show of being angry at the things they believe Americans should be angry about. To his credit, Sen. Chris Van Hollen flew to El Salvador to meet with prisoner Kilmar Abrego Garcia personally, after Trump's new program of renditions illegally sent Garcia to a for-profit Salvadoran prison infamous for abuse and torture.
It was timely. It was an overt, intentional act of decency. It was an effort to spur public debate, not cower from it.
The House and Senate have many such Democrats, and it is malpractice to stifle those basic acts of public politicking in favor of ... what? There seems no proposed alternative. While individual senators and members of congress highlight acts of administration corruption and vow to devote themselves to investigating and exposing them, Democratic leadership has not, two weeks after election night, relayed any similar vision. The Democratic stereotype of caution to the point of paralysis is waiting just offstage; the whole world is wondering whether it will be the next act or whether the party has found another.
Over on the House side, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is making his own case for continued leadership. There is no real challenge to JEffries as new House speaker, but nonetheless he is making more aggressive noises for change than might have been expected.
Jeffries, who is the heavy favorite to become speaker of the House on Jan. 3, said Democrats should use their “historic” House majority and “robust” Senate majority to lower the Medicare eligibility age and expand coverage under the program to include benefits for dental, vision and hearing.
He also backed universal health coverage for children.
“We should lower the age of Medicare eligibility. We should expand coverage to include vision, hearing, and dental. And we should cover all the kids in the United States of America,” Jeffries said Tuesday in response to a question from NBC News. “Those are bold actions, meaningful actions, important actions that can be taken on our march toward universal health coverage.”
The remarks by Jeffries go significantly further than the pre-election health care agenda he laid out in September, which focused on undoing President Donald Trump’s Medicaid spending cuts and restoring enhanced Affordable Care Act tax credits that expired in January.
This is good politics and plausible policy; it would force Republicans and Trump alike to oppose those things directly; even if Trump refuses to sign such expansions, they demonstrate both a Democratic Party plan to fix a healthcare system that has gone from grift-filled to crooked to full-on collapse. It forces the conversation forward; it promises something that might change if voters stand by Democrats two years from now rather than throwing up their hands with a new example of nothing ever changes.
If the rest of the world's obvious solution, government-run health insurance for all, is too heavy a lift, then keep expanding Medicare and Medicaid to encompass more and more of the population, working out new kinks along the way.
It is not my preferred solution: Seizing the assets of all health insurance providers, nationalizing coverage, before ceremonially eating each company's top executives on national tv.
Compromises, however, can be made.
Jeffries is another leader whose timidity has not aged well in the face of authoritarian escalations. If his own ambitions are motivating him to adopt a more aggressive tone, then good for him; if Schumer has such self-preservation skills he has seldom shown it. Schumer's political approach has always been to present himself and his own policy choices as fait accompli, adopting a chastising tone with those who seek more while expressing more sympathy to those who want less.
And this is the approach that voters who are this angry and this willing to rout even longtime allies will simply not put up with. It's a recipe for voter retaliation against Democrats on the next election day, because if voters are rilling to rouse themselves to this extent it is because they want the bad things to stop, not bipartisanship or five point plans or technocratic position papers.
What has Schumer done to indicate that he shares the anger now sweeping through the country? Not much. What is he proposing that he would not have proposed two years ago? It's not clear.
And even if he was, it is not clear whether voters would buy that one of the most visible symbols of Democratic Party mealy-mouthedness and reticence has now flipped to become the agent of aggressive change that a wave election intends as mandate.
Whether it's Schumer's own fault is irrelevant. The times have changed, and the party needs to project the same urgency that furious voters are now expecting to see.
Schumer's defenders maintain that the position of Senate majority leader entails more private work than public, and that Schumer's private work is far more effective than his public appearances suggest.
That may very well be true, but his inability to articulate any vision that resonates with the public—even as fascism rises up around us—is disqualifying.
Let a new generation of leaders come forward. Do not mumble about change; change. Do not focus group anger about injustice; be genuinely angry. This election elevated Democratic voices who met Republican vice signaling with virtue signaling, loud and urgent and proud—those voices were rewarded. Voters came out to condemn the deportations, the baffling and costly tariff and war regimes, and the sight of a president painting Washington, D.C. in gold while the rest of us see every income gain met five times over by new insurance premiums and a scam-and-gambling economy of cheats.
Enough. The party needs to change. It cannot be led by an old guard that has proven unable to.
Comments
We want Uncharted Blue to be a welcoming and progressive space.
Before commenting, make sure you've read our Community Guidelines.